 Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.757 ) |
日期：2007/04/26 13:23
留言者：百事可樂
 |
同是天涯淪落人一曲，假如倆位姊姊真的是初學，你們的師傅就有點兒問題了!
當然只上了四課，只用卡拉OK 來練習，成果是不會好，因粵曲真是一門高深的學問
要用長時間去浸，去學，如老三哥哥講，你們的天份已經很好了，只是改進的空間
太多，對一般初學粵曲者，應從淺入深，由一些較簡單的曲本開始，同是天涯淪
落人並不是一首容易唱的曲，沒有一定的基本功，唱來只有難聽的感覺。不明白你
們的師傅為何沒有給你們提點? 呀! 可能你的師傅覺得好容易唱，高人! 高人! 佩服! 佩服!
平喉已經是十分勉強去聽，子喉的音色全無，更不用提唱腔，發口等等。
只見倆位姊姊在備註上寫明 "希望各位網友能給予寶貴意見"，想必是虛心求學，
小妹才斗膽講出真心話，請倆位切勿見怪或氣餒。只望日候多加努力，唱好一些，
才放上網，與眾曲友共賞!
|
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.758 ) |
日期：2007/04/26 21:35
留言者：頑皮友
 |
百事可樂：
我都有同感,這隻曲運腔,跌蕩,高音的技巧運用,發聲的完美,
是比較考功夫的,初学者應該避免唱的,由淺入深才是.   |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.759 ) |
日期：2007/04/27 01:34
留言者：楓林月
|
「同是天涯淪落人」一曲應該是在宋錦榮師傅局收錄吧. 掌板是宋師傅, 下手是葉盛華、宋耀基, 頭架是林日章或黎国鴻, 橫笛是鄺家章, 琵琶蔡穎, 楊琴是李偉覺, 亦可能是譚穎如, 等等. |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.760 ) |
日期：2007/04/27 21:06
留言者：Jade 2
|
回覆百事可樂師姐：
謝謝你肯講出真心話，因為在我們的朋友、曲友、甚至是師傅群中，從來套不到他們一句真心的評語，才大膽把此曲放在大笪地，目的是想得到真心的評語，也知到會辛苦了你們的耳朵，很是抱歉。現在聽了這麼多的真心話，心頭如放下一大石，心情輕鬆得多了，因為以後上課及練曲時，再不會有壓力，我們不會迫速自已，因為欲速不達，一切順其自然，隨緣便是！其次，我們師傅並沒有要我們學這曲，是因為我們愛讀白居易的 '琵琶行'，更喜歡這首曲的音韻，才求師傅教授此曲。
以後我們會儘量挑選一些容易唱的曲來學習，聽從你和頑皮友師傅的指引。
From J.T. & M.T.
P.S. to 楓林月: 正是。
|
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.761 ) |
日期：2007/04/27 13:25
留言者：sam
|
learning is a living process. One does not have to follow a set patterm or routine. As long as you do not feel too difficult or over taxing, any song is a good song to learn with. |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.762 ) |
日期：2007/04/27 13:59
留言者：Tim
|
麻pin外子, 麻pin -- 水漫金山
"青蛇是由男平演譯。" .........................都算創新!?
  |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.763 ) |
日期：2007/04/27 22:33
留言者：Jade 2
|
Hi Sam,
You're most insightful and wise. A real gentleman too! I like your input for you always give such positive feedback to people! That means a lot to me because your constructive comments do give me hope again and make me want to go forward instead of giving it all up (on CO)! My sister and I will keep on trying to better ourselves... Thx.
|
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.764 ) |
日期：2007/04/28 01:14
留言者：Critique
 |
People always expect and enjoy good comments rather than the truth. Whenever you tell someone the truth, you are the worst one. Ha! Ha! As a beginner of Cantonese Opera, it is good to start with an easy one. Of course, once you earned enough experience and techniques, you can have your own pattern. For instance, how could a kindergarten kid write a fiction without learning ABC or a baby didn’t learn how to walk, how could the baby run. I agreed to give encouragement to the beginner, but with a good heart and wisdom.
|
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.765 ) |
日期：2007/04/29 05:30
留言者：IloVeUalL
|
Why do educators work so hard to develop 'pattern and routine' for MOST things in Learning?
Because it makes sense and it helps.
Why is there no rules to determine at what level to sing what song?
Because it is a free world.
YOU decide - with your wisdom, hopefully.
 |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.766 ) |
日期：2007/04/28 22:26
留言者：平子喉
 |
So, can anybody comment 胡笳十八拍? no matter they are good or not. Its helpful for us to get improvement, we are also green horn in CO, thanks. |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.767 ) |
日期：2007/04/30 12:41
留言者：麻pin
網頁：http://adcoa.spymac.com
|
Tim: 多謝垂注。 |
|
| Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁 ( No.768 ) |
日期：2007/04/30 14:49
留言者：mulan
電郵：mulan.chan@gmail.com
 |
Sam
Agree with you 100%. I'm one of the examples, just sing away as I really enjoy doing it when I have chosen a song that I could put my feelings into it!! And pretend that I sang like the singer.
Jade 2
Don't give up. Slow and steady will ... I started singing CO more than 2 years ago. Still struggling singing well and interest getting stronger ... |
|
粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁