粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) 日期：2009/01/01 21:45 留言者：阿立，阿藍 大笪地演出的曲友，絕大多數的都是業餘愛好者，不是專業唱家，能夠寄曲在此一展歌喉，實須莫大的勇氣，亦是我們應該鼓勵及支持的，我們更相信，演出者一定渴望各位曲友能夠對他們的曲藝提出寶貴的意見，使能更上一層樓。 沒有唱曲是可完美無瑕的，各人唱功亦深淺有異，大笪地水準參差，是十分正常的，我們希望大眾曲友，能抱著互勵互勉的精神，聽曲後給予回應，作為對演出的曲友一個實質的支持，我深信，只要是善意的批評，各演出者定然樂於接受。 此專頁亦歡迎各演出者就曲友的回應在此互相討論。 按此進入粵曲大笪地 請注意： 1) 各曲友的回應，無論正面或負面，全屬個人意見，祗供作參考之用，如需精確詳盡的品評及指導，演出者應詢問其專業老師。 2) 本專頁衹為回應唱曲而設，網主會刪除所有無關的留言，而且要求會比所有其他留言區嚴格，請諒。 3) 嚴禁惡意批評對唱曲回應的曲友，所有此類留言，均被視作不友善及會被刪除。 4) 嚴禁用化名自己評自己的曲, 犯規者的曲目會被下除。

Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66]

< 回上一頁

Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.269 ) 日期：2008/01/14 20:39 留言者：sam 琴挑 Male voice ...seems to put a fair bit of emphasis on the end of each singing 'sentence". This makes the beginning of the sentences weak in volume and clarity. More importantly the end notes often ending off key, too high in this case. Best example is in the first sentence of the song. Many 'Lie Hong' notes get muddled together. Make each note crisp and clear. Female tends to be a bit 'peel' or floating. Many notes are not held long enough or sung a bit off key. overall experience shown and the song was sung effortlessly. Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.270 ) 日期：2008/01/15 13:43 留言者：Susan Dear Sam, 我很懷疑你和師傅仔是同一人, 分別在你用英文寫評語,而他是用中文, 但大家的聽粵曲的品味也差不多, 而評語也好像一胍相承. 師傅仔不知否巳随嫦娥2號樓身於太空,不問塵世事. 因上之次呂廖二人送(聲聲慢)的TAPE, 師傅仔下了一個不客氣的評語, 而令廖家平不高興, 而令到師傅仔連聲SAY SORRY.不知今次會否事件重演 HELLO, BOTH OF YOU ARE SAME ONE ? Susan Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.271 ) 日期：2008/01/15 21:41 留言者：sam i do not say sorry.......SUUUSAN I mean not that often. I say sorry to my parents a lot. Even now when they are very old and i am old. I also apologize to 鍾沅芳 recently. I do not think that giving a constructive opinion here needs any apology. This point has been discussed many times over in the past. Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.272 ) 日期：2008/01/15 20:38 留言者：sam oooook. I make this one exception to reply to you. I am I, me, self....sam I have never used any name apart from sam, except once for a specific reason. That time i told ah lap straight away by email and explain why i did that. I am no 師傅 and certainly not 師傅仔. If anything I have expressed my strong dislike towards the practice of people using different names on this web site before. When i found out a frequent submitter of songs who then used a different name to give opinion on his own songs I stop listening to his songs. And never reply to hs message. I got mix up with cantonese opera for only a few years. I do not sing. I only dabble in instruments...and fairly bad at that. I think i have an ear for the most basic of the basics of music. That is why I mostly comment on people who sing off key or bad timing. ANything more than that i am no expert and no 師傅. 師傅仔 appears to me to be a very knowledgable fellow. It is an honour to get mixed up with him.!!! sam is sam. no other name. from melbourne. Yes, often people get annoyed by me. disliked by many too. But not often do i say sorry. Sorry Susan............... Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.273 ) 日期：2008/01/15 21:09 留言者：betty 琴挑 A nice song, great singers! Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.274 ) 日期：2008/01/15 23:06 留言者：Susan Dear Sam, I think you disunderstood me,i do not want you to say sorry. when I learned your comment of piano, you described her singing technique: tends to a bit peel or floating that like 師傅仔當時的一句話唱到好似漬牙膏 Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.275 ) 日期：2008/01/15 23:25 留言者：Susan Dear Sam, I think you disunderstood me,i do not want you to say sorry. when I learned your comment of piano, you described her singing technique: tends to a bit peel or floating that like 師傅仔當時的一句話唱到好似漬牙膏that's let me to link two songs had similer comment so I have an imagine for that it so sorry let you misunderstood. when this case was happened you have not yet joy this party, the finally outcome was brother ah lap to solved the promble and 師傅仔say sorry. afterward I didn't see any article at this site, maybe he use other name. Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.276 ) 日期：2008/01/15 23:49 留言者：sam that is ok. i cannot write too much. Otherwise i have to trouble ah lap to post my words for me again!! Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.278 ) 日期：2008/01/16 05:00 留言者：黄衫客 琴挑： 以上两位寫英文的評曲人,請勿吵鬧了.代我做中間人吧. 以他們的一把年紀,唱了几十年的功力,早上擦了牙就唱,比我們唱多十倍八倍. 他們唱得比師父仔評曲時大有進步,平喉聲線都近似陳小漢 B哥的音階.比我想像中大有進步, 只有少少跟不到音樂. 子喉的聲線都很好,叮板音色都不錯,他們周遊列国,一定有名師指導. 只是開始 [芳菲]两字要練練,[抱]字要咬實,其他都很好 Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.280 ) 日期：2008/01/16 09:09 留言者：青天 唱琴挑的兩位曲友都是放曲上網的常客，他們在隔離網站常擺放多首名曲。奇怪的是隔離網站好像沒有限制放曲數量。 相信他們的表演慾也不少哩！ Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.281 ) 日期：2008/01/16 09:35 留言者：藍天 歷史又重演了. Re: 粵曲大笪地之曲友回應專頁(二) ( No.282 ) 日期：2008/01/16 14:19 留言者：Susan 黃衫客, 我不是在在吵閙, 事緣我只是遊戲人間式寫出我的感覺, 可能SAM是一個處事比較嚴謹的人, 至令他有所誤會要SAY SORRY.我維有用my kindergarden englsih vs his tertiary english. 原來SAM 是 ABC,怪不得他要用英文寫comment. 師傅仔雖不是字字珠璣, 但偶有神來之筆, 令人會心微笑, I still miss him Sam, 如有不敬之處,請多多包涵

Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66]

< 回上一頁

- 阿立粵曲天地 -
聲明